Q92 · Practice questionComplex unfamiliar20 marks
QUESTION 92 (20 marks)
A government is choosing a response to an ageing population. Use all four sources to evaluate a savings incentive and work/training support. Recommend the more effective option using sustainable economic growth and equity.
Source 2
Retirees with limited savings face hardship. The proposed non-refundable savings credit is unavailable to households with no income-tax liability.
Source 3
Employers report skill shortages. Training completion takes two years; flexible hours and childcare can remove participation barriers earlier.
Source 4
Some additional saving finances domestic investment, but participation in the incentive may partly replace existing saving rather than create new saving.
ANSWER
Work/training support is better supported for broad capacity and equity, with targeted retirement-income protection as a complement.
At equal fiscal cost, Source 1 projects seven times as many additional labour-force participants under support (35 000 versus 5000). Source 3 links the intervention to real shortages and participation barriers, so it can expand effective labour supply and sustainable output. The two-year training lag requires staged delivery and suitable vacancies. The savings incentive could support capital formation (Source 4), but substitution for existing saving reduces additionality. Its non-refundable design excludes no-tax-liability households facing hardship (Source 2), weakening equity. Work support is therefore the stronger main choice on the stated criteria, but not everyone can return to work: an appropriate safety net remains important. Higher participation can temporarily raise measured unemployment if matching is slow; that is different from permanent job destruction. Evaluate net jobs, retention, access and productive investment as the program matures.
Explains ageing, effective labour supply and productive capacity.
Uses equal cost and the 7:1 participant comparison.
Evaluates credit eligibility and retirement hardship using equity.
Evaluates training lags, job matching and savings additionality.
Synthesises a recommendation with relevant complementary protection.
Explains a meaningful uncertainty or monitoring measure.