Q91 · Practice questionComplex unfamiliar20 marks
QUESTION 91 (20 marks)
A drought disrupts food production and freight. Use all four sources to evaluate a broad cash rebate against targeted freight repair. Recommend a response using price stability and full employment. Explain how monetary policy could complement the chosen response.
Source 2
Businesses report that damaged freight links, rather than weak orders, are their main production constraint. Repairs can be substantially completed within nine months.
Source 3
The rebate reaches households within one month. Low-income households face immediate difficulty purchasing essential food.
Source 4
Inflation expectations have increased. Most mortgages are variable-rate, but employment is already weakening.
ANSWER
Targeted repair is the stronger main response on the supplied forecasts; temporary targeted household relief and careful monetary restraint may complement it.
Source 2 identifies a supply bottleneck, so simply increasing spending does not repair the cause. In Source 1, repair raises growth 1.0 percentage point above baseline while reducing inflation 0.9 point; the rebate raises growth 0.7 point but adds 0.8 point to inflation. At equal $8 billion public cost, repair better reconciles output/employment and prices. Its nine-month implementation lag leaves vulnerable households exposed (Source 3), supporting limited, targeted relief rather than an indiscriminate rebate. Source 4 raises concern about persistent expectations: monetary policy may restrain demand and anchor them, but cannot manufacture food or fix roads, and strong tightening would add employment and mortgage pressure. A staged mix is justified, with monitoring of repair delivery and inflation persistence. Forecasts are conditional; another conclusion needs to confront both the bottleneck and household hardship.
Identifies the supply shock and distinguishes demand relief from restored capacity.
Uses the two forecast comparisons and equal fiscal costs.
Integrates household hardship and repair timing.
Evaluates the two stated objectives and justifies a recommendation.
Explains monetary complementarity, expectations and employment trade-offs.
Qualifies the forecasts and acknowledges a defensible alternative.