Q52 · Practice questionComplex familiar5 marks
QUESTION 52 (5 marks)
A government’s deficit rises from $20 billion to $30 billion. Its estimated cyclical deficit rises from $5 billion to $25 billion. Calculate the structural deficit in each period and assess the claim that the larger headline deficit proves discretionary fiscal policy became more expansionary.
ANSWER
Structural deficit: $15 billion then $5 billion; the headline change does not prove discretionary expansion.
Using total deficit = cyclical + structural deficit, the estimates are 20 − 5 = 15 and 30 − 25 = 5 billion. The underlying deficit narrows by $10 billion while the cycle worsens the headline balance. This is consistent with a less expansionary underlying position. Structural estimates are uncertain and do not by themselves identify every policy measure.
Calculates both structural estimates.
Distinguishes cyclical deterioration from underlying change.
Qualifies the inference rather than relying on the headline deficit.