Q124 · Practice questionComplex familiar5 marks
QUESTION 124 (5 marks)
Seedlings of one species are grown in a controlled experiment with two maintained soil-moisture levels and two light treatments. Each treatment starts with 30 seedlings and is repeated six times. Other conditions are held similar. The table gives mean survivors after four weeks.
| Soil moisture | Full light | Shade |
|---|---|---|
| Low | 3 | 15 |
| High | 24 | 25 |
a) Describe how the effect of shade differs between the two moisture levels. Use numerical evidence. [2 marks]
b) Give a biological explanation consistent with the greater benefit of shade under low moisture. [2 marks]
c) Explain why the repeated treatments are useful. [1 mark]
ANSWER
Low-moisture survival increases from 3 to 15 with shade; high-moisture survival changes from 24 to 25. Shade has a much larger survival association under low moisture.
At low moisture, shade adds 12 survivors on average; at high moisture it adds only one. The species is strongly limited by water in full light. Shade can reduce evaporative water stress even when maintained soil-moisture levels differ. The treatment effect should be compared within each moisture level rather than assumed constant across them.
Identifies increases of 12 at low moisture and 1 at high moisture.
States that shade has the larger effect under low moisture.
Identifies water stress or greater water loss in full light.
Links shade to reduced water stress and increased survival.
Explains that replication reduces reliance on a single unusual trial or reveals variation.