Q123 · Practice questionComplex familiar6 marks
QUESTION 123 (6 marks)
The curves show cumulative plant-species counts from randomly located equal-sized quadrats in habitats X and Y. Within each habitat, no previously recorded species is removed from the cumulative total.
a) Compare the observed richness rankings at 6 and 18 quadrats, referring to the graph. [2 marks]
b) Explain why the six-quadrat comparison could give a misleading ranking of the habitats. [2 marks]
c) Explain what the flattening curves suggest about additional sampling, and state one limit of that inference. [2 marks]
ANSWER
At 6 quadrats Y appears richer (20 versus 12). By 18 quadrats X is richer (30 versus 22). Late flattening supports more complete coverage, while six quadrats missed many X species.
Early species accumulation can be slower where species are rare or clumped. At six quadrats the observed richness is not yet close to the later X plateau. Around 18–24 quadrats both curves flatten, with X near 30 and Y near 22. A plateau suggests diminishing discoveries under this protocol, without proving every species was found.
States Y > X at 6 quadrats, with values 20 and 12.
States X > Y at 18 quadrats, with values 30 and 22.
Identifies incomplete sampling in X at six quadrats.
Links different discovery rates to rare or clumped species, or differing completeness.
States that additional quadrats are yielding few new species.
Notes that unobserved rare species may remain or that other methods/times may reveal more.