QUESTION 4 (6 marks)
An ecologist investigated the species composition of mangrove trees in a natural mangrove forest and an adjacent 30-year-old planted mangrove forest. Three 10 m-wide belt transects were sampled from inland to the sea for each of the forests, each covering 100 m on average and placed to cover various strata. The species diversity of Forest A was determined using the Simpson’s Diversity Index (SDI):
Population count | ||
Species | Forest A (natural) | Forest B (planted) |
Grey mangrove | 91 | 77 |
Red mangrove | 23 | 14 |
River mangrove | 11 | 8 |
Orange mangrove | 3 | 0 |
Diversity | 0.46 | ? |
a) Use the SDI formula to calculate the diversity index for Forest B. Round your answer to two decimal places.
[2 marks]
b) Identify three reasons why the ecologist used a belt transect rather than line transects or randomly placed quadrats for collecting data to compare these two forests.
[3 marks]
c) Identify one way in which the ecologist minimised bias in the sampling.
[1 mark]
QCAA guide · typeset solution
QCAA sample response and mark allocation
4 | a) | SDI= 1 −77(77 −1) + 14(14 −1) + 8(8 −1)99(99 −1)= 0.37 | For substitution, accept: 1 −77 × 76 + 14 × 13 + 8 × 7 99 × 98 1 −5852 + 182 + 56 9702 1 −6090 9702 or other suitable response consistent with a reasonable understanding. | ||
4 | b) | Belt transects are used for abundance and distribution of species. Random quadrats can be used for abundance, not distribution, and line transects can be used for distribution, not abundance. Random sampling doesn’t take into account strata (different areas) and may not cover all areas of habitat equally, giving inaccurate measures of diversity and abundance. | • states 3 reasons | 3 marks | Reasons include: belt transects gather species types and abundance random sampling does not consider strata line transects only consider distribution. |
• states 2 reasons | 2 marks | ||||
• states a reason | 1 mark | ||||
• does not satisfy any of the descriptors above. | 0 | ||||
4 | c) | The locations of belt transects were chosen to take strata into account. | • states a way to minimise bias [1 mark] | Ways to minimise bias include: location of belt transacts use of multiple transects size of sample (100 m x 10 m is a large sample, and there are three of them). |
QCAA sample response and marking criteria reproduced from the official guide.
Compare your working with the guide above.