Q276 · Practice questionTechnology-freeComplex familiar6 marks
QUESTION 276 (6 marks)
Three teams A, B and C play a mini-tournament. A defeats B, B defeats C, and C defeats A. Let Dij=1 when team i defeats team j and 0 otherwise, with order A, B, C.
a)
Construct D and determine the row-sum scores of D+D2.
[2 marks]
b)
An organiser says changing the model to D+qD2 for positive q will produce a unique ranking. Evaluate the claim.
[2 marks]
c)
Propose one refinement that could distinguish the teams. State any additional information it would require.
(c) Use score margins, or arrange an additional playoff.
(a) D2=010001100. Each row sum of D+D2 is 2.
(b) Every row of D and D2 has sum 1. Thus each row of D+qD2 has sum 1+q for every positive q. Changing the weight cannot break this symmetry.
(c) A score-margin matrix can distinguish teams if margins differ, but requires actual match scores. A playoff supplies new outcomes. Relabelling tied teams is not a mathematical distinction in performance.
Equivalent justified methods accepted; respect any requested proof method.
Exact values unless specified. Sketches assessed by mathematical features, not artistic quality.
Part a: Construct D using the stated convention.
[1 mark]
Part a: Calculate the three scores correctly.
[1 mark]
Part b: Express each score as 1+q.
[1 mark]
Part b: Explain why the tie remains.
[1 mark]
Part c: Propose a defensible refinement.
[1 mark]
Part c: State the extra data or new outcomes needed.