Q147 · Practice questionComplex familiar6 marks
QUESTION 147 (6 marks)
A heritable body-size trait has three categories. A selection episode produces the survival counts shown. No migration or reproduction occurs during the episode.
| Category | Size / units | Before | Survivors |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small | 4 | 20 | 18 |
| Medium | 6 | 60 | 12 |
| Large | 8 | 20 | 18 |
a) Calculate survival percentages for the three categories. [2 marks]
b) Identify the selection type and justify from the pattern. [2 marks]
c) Show that mean body size remains unchanged, and explain why this does not show that selection was absent. [2 marks]
ANSWER
Small and large survival is 90%; medium survival is 20%. The data support disruptive selection. The mean size remains 6 units because the losses are symmetric, even though the distribution becomes more weighted towards both extremes.
Survival percentages are 18/20 = 90%, 12/60 = 20%, and 18/20 = 90%. Both extremes are favoured relative to the middle. Before, mean = (20×4+60×6+20×8)/100 = 6; after, mean = (18×4+12×6+18×8)/48 = 6. An unchanged mean can conceal a large distributional change.
Calculates 90% for each extreme.
Calculates 20% for medium individuals.
Identifies disruptive selection.
Uses favoured extremes and reduced intermediate survival.
Calculates means of 6 units before and after.
Explains that distribution/relative category frequencies can change while the mean stays constant.